The Challenge
Growth consultants are expensive. Their value is real but it lives almost entirely in their heads — pattern recognition built over decades, applied to client situations through instinct, experience, and frameworks that are never fully documented. The question was whether that intuition could be systematised. Captured, trained, and deployed at a fraction of the cost.
It was a genuinely interesting question. Interesting enough to take seriously, which meant working with people who actually knew what they were talking about — university AI research units, business school academics, and psychology departments who studied how experts make decisions.
The Approach
Spent significant time across those university departments mapping the problem properly. The AI researchers were honest about what the models could and could not do. The psychologists helped deconstruct what consultant intuition actually consisted of at a cognitive level. The business academics understood the methodology being encoded.
The conclusion, reached collaboratively and without drama, was that replacing a consultant's full intuitive process was not a near-term possibility without an investment that no business case could justify. The complexity was real. The cutting-edge research was genuinely cutting edge — meaning nobody had solved it yet, and the cost of being the first to do so was prohibitive. The grant application that might have changed that equation was unsuccessful.
So the scope was reduced. Significantly.
The Outcomes
Rather than replacing consultant intuition, built a Small Language Model focused on a narrower, more tractable problem — organisational diagnostics. Not replacing the consultant. Not replicating their full judgement. Just compressing the diagnostic phase — the structured information gathering, pattern identification, and initial hypothesis generation — into something faster and more consistent than doing it manually every time.
It saves weeks. It does not replace humans. It was never going to, and being honest about that earlier would have saved some time. The research conversations with the university units were valuable regardless — they gave a clearer picture of where AI genuinely is versus where the marketing says it is, which turns out to be a useful thing to know.
AI · SLM · Consulting · Diagnostics · Research · Scope Management · Honest Failure